SERVE Home Page
SERVE Center for Continuous Improvement
 Overview
 Products & Publications
 Professional Development
Tools & Resources
 Assessment Subtopics :
       Classroom Level
       School Level
       State Level
       Accountability for
       Instructional Quality

  

Topic Areas Emerging Issues About SERVE
SERVE > Topic Areas > Assessment > Accountability for Instructional Quality > Selecting A Focus > Authentic Assessment Quality

 

 

Authentic Assessment Quality

Paper and pencil, computer-scored state tests do not begin to assess the competencies that large majorities of adults agree are essential today: the ability to comprehend difficult reading material and apply information to the solution of complex problems; the ability to write and speak clearly and thoughtfully; the ability to understand mathematical data and use math and technology as problem-solving tools; the ability to work effectively in teams; and finally, respect for others and an understanding of our roles as citizens”.

—Tony Wagner, Co-Director of the Change Leadership Group at Harvard University's Graduate School of Education

 

 


Recognizing the key role of challenging performance-based assessments in developing students' ability to think, reason, and communicate their knowledge, in the late 1990s, the Regional Educational Laboratories developed a Toolkit for Professional Developers to use in training teachers in the use of alternative or performance-based assessment methods (see Toolkit98). The need to encourage teachers to go beyond multiple-choice tests and demand more challenging intellectual work from their students is still with us.

As teachers are not always comfortable in the role of assessment developer, an important issue for schools and districts to consider is how to support teachers in critiquing the quality of the alternative or performance-based assessments they use. The Alternative Assessment Evaluation Form is one such tool. The criteria used are ones that reflect agreed upon criteria for high quality assessments. This Alternative Assessment Evaluation Form can be used by groups of teachers in critiquing their performance assessments. Chapter 3 (Designing High Quality Assessments ) describes what good assessments look like. Several activities are suggested as a way of working with teachers in critiquing performance assessment quality (Activity 3.1 is called Performance Tasks—Keys to Success and Activity 3.6 is called How to Critique an Assessment .

Some resources for performance assessments:



Back