| |
Critical Issue: Meeting the Diverse Needs of Young Children
ISSUE: The increase in racial, ethnic, and cultural diversity in
American schools is reflected in many early childhood classrooms. These classrooms also
are receiving increased numbers of children with disabilities or developmental delays. The
diverse composition of early childhood classrooms brings many challenges as well as many
opportunities to educators. With a knowledge of effective practices, and with the support
of administrators, colleagues, families, and the local and global community, teachers can
create classrooms that are responsive to the diverse needs of all children.
Overview | Goals | Action Options | Pitfalls | Different Viewpoints | Cases | Contacts
|
OVERVIEW: By the year 2000, more than 30
percent of the U.S. population will have a racial- or ethnic-minority background (Office
of Ethnic Minority Affairs, 1995). If the children of those families were evenly
distributed across the nation's classrooms, a hypothetical class of 30 children would have
10 students from racial- or ethnic-minority groups; of these 10, six children would belong
to families for whom English is not the home language, and two to four children would have
limited English proficiency (National Center for Research on Cultural Diversity and
Second Language Learning, n.d.). Although the United States traditionally has been a
culturally and linguistically diverse nation, today's schools have an increased awareness
of the need to acknowledge and address issues of diversity.
Children with special needs also are increasingly represented in general education
classrooms. Federal laws relating to children with disabilities, such as the Education for
All Handicapped Children Act (Public Law 94-142), specify that all students who have
disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate public education, regardless of skill
levels or severity of disability, in the least-restrictive environment possible. Questions
and answers relating to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act Amendments of 1997
can help schools that are trying to conform to the requirements of this recent
legislation. Federal law dovetails with attempts to incorporate disabled students in
regular classrooms, from some type of mainstreaming (which brings students with
disabilities into regular classrooms for some classes) to full inclusion. These efforts
make students with disabilities more visible in every type of school setting, including
the early education classroom.
|
Brenda Rodriguez, interim director for the Chicago Public Schools project of the
Center for School and Community Development at North Central Regional Educational
Laboratory, discusses the challenges educators face in thinking about diversity in the
classroom.
[588k
audio file] Excerpted from a videotaped interview with Brenda Rodriguez (North
Central Regional Educational Laboratory, 1998). |
If schools are to meet the challenge of educating increased numbers of children with
diverse needs, teachers must embrace instruction and curricula that engage and encourage
all students. Research about including children from multicultural backgrounds, children
from homes in which English is not the primary language, and children with disabilities
indicates the importance of several interrelated educational strategies: heterogeneous
student grouping, developmentally appropriate practice, an inclusive curriculum that
emphasizes children's strengths yet accommodates their needs, high expectations for all
students, appropriate physical environment and materials, collaboration and instructional
teaming with other teachers and professionals, support from administrators, families, and
the community, and ongoing professional development.
Heterogeneous Student Grouping. Research on grouping practices has shown
the detrimental impact of identifying students from minority racial, ethnic, and language
backgrounds as low achievers and placing them in "lower" tracks. Villegas
(1991) notes: "High and low academic tracks or instructional groups constitute
different interactional contexts. Rather than narrowing the gap between the groups, the
instructional methods typically used with the less-advanced students tend to accentuate
any inequality in skills and knowledge that may be present when children are initially
admitted to school." (p. 5)
Similarly, grouping students with disabilities in special education classrooms may isolate
them from the real world and limit their opportunities to interact with other children.
When circumstances permit, including students with disabilities in general education
classrooms is highly desirable for promoting learning as well as social relationships.
Research shows positive results--both socially and academically--for at-risk,
ethnic-minority, and language-minority students in heterogeneous, cooperative learning
groups (Oakes, 1985; Wheelock, 1992; Johnson & Johnson, 1990; Slavin, 1990,
Benard, 1995; Garcia, 1991). The teacher responsible for such a heterogeneous class
must be able to identify the individual needs of each child, including any needs for
accommodation and support. Assessment of young children can be a formal method for
screening, diagnosis, determining eligibility for special services, planning instruction,
and placement. Assessment also can be a means for monitoring progress through an
Individualized Education Plan or Individualized Family Service Plan, which are required by
law for children with disabilities. Further, assessment can be an informal determination
of any extra help that an individual child may need in the classroom (Wolery, 1994a).
Observations and conversations with family members, as well as formal test information,
can help the teacher build upon each childs strengths, regardless of whether the
child is disabled, has a primary language other than English, or is from an
ethnic-minority group (Dodge & Colker, 1992; Sanchez, Li, & Nuttall, 1995).
This "advocacy orientation" can have positive results in empowering students,
notes Cummins (1991). It is a positive contrast to the approach that labels a
child "deficient" and produces a program to provide what he or she lacks.
Developmentally Appropriate Practice. Developmentally appropriate practice is "based
on knowledge about how children develop and learn" (National Association for the
Eduation of Young Children, 1996). According to the Southern Regional Education Board
(1994), a developmentally appropriate early childhood program emphasizes the
following:
- Active, senses-based exploration of the environment
- Self-directed, hands-on learning activities balanced with teacher-directed activities
- A balance between individual and group activities
- Regular and supportive interaction with teachers and peers
- A balance between active movement and quiet activities
- Ongoing observation and assessment, which informs the program
When early childhood professionals make decisions about the developmental
appropriateness of practices, they rely on three types of information and knowledge: what
is known about child development and learning; what is known about the strengths,
interests, and needs of each individual child in the group; and knowledge of the social
and cultural context in which children live (National Association for the Education of
Young Children, 1996). Developmentally appropriate practice is especially important
in the diverse early education classroom because it encourages greater cultural
sensitivity, recognizes a variety of cultural communication patterns, and allows for
intervention in the natural course of teaching.
Developmentally appropriate practice encourages greater cultural sensitivity because it
emphasizes the use of an interactive or experiential teaching model marked by guidance and
facilitation rather than control of student learning by the teacher. This type of
instruction, notes Cummins (1991), "is automatically culture-fair in that
all students are actively involved in expressing, sharing, and amplifying their
experiences within the classroom." It is especially appropriate for language-minority
children because it provides enriching experiences that each child can act upon
individually (Nissani, 1993). Research shows that children with disabilities also
benefit from this interactive or experiential approach because it emphasizes the child's
engaged exploration (Swedo, 1987; Willig, Swedo, and Ortiz, 1987; Wolery, 1994d).
The developmentally appropriate interactive approach allows teachers to adapt classroom
interaction to accommodate various cultural communication patterns. Such patterns include
the role of eye contact in interacting with adults, the amount of time a student considers
appropriate before responding, the type of sequence used in storytelling, and the sharing
of information in a group. For example, some cultures discourage calling attention to
oneself and showing knowledge; children from this type of background may not participate
verbally in classroom activities (see Quintero, 1994; Villegas, 1991). By
identifying and acknowledging cultural communication patterns, teachers can help children
become comfortable and confident in the classroom setting. McLaughlin (1995)
notes: "By validating the students cultures and using communication patterns
familiar to them, teachers provide a much richer and more effective approach to culturally
sensitive instruction than by focusing on occasional celebrations of the history and
traditions of different ethnic groups. Children will feel validated in the classroom if
they are encouraged to acclimate gradually through daily affirmation of their learning
styles and communication patterns."
In addition to validating culture, the developmentally appropriate teaching style allows
teachers to work with the different ways that children acquire languageboth their
first language and a second language. For example, children may learn a second language
simultaneously with or successively to first-language acquisition and with or without
code-switching, or inserting single items from one language into the other to make meaning
clear (McLaughlin, 1995). Developing sensitivity to children's language use and
acquisition helps teachers put into practice the viewpoint that bilingualism is an asset,
not a deficit to be remedied (Gomez, 1991).
Developmentally appropriate practice promotes naturalistic teaching strategies. Such
strategies integrate childrens individual goals into instruction by allowing
teachers to intervene immediately in the context of naturally occurring classroom
activities. Immediate teacher intervention can improve the language skills of a student
whose home language is not English (Nissani, 1993); it also can assist a disabled
student in reaching developmental goals such as feeding oneself or asking appropriately
for juice at snack time (Diamond, Hestenes, & OConnor, 1994). If
students demonstrate unwelcome behavior (such as prejudice), natural intervention allows
the teacher to immediately address the issue (Derman-Sparks & Anti-Bias Curriculum
Task Force, 1989).
An Inclusive Curriculum. Another strategy for teaching children in a
diverse classroom is an inclusive curriculum that emphasizes the strengths but
accommodates the needs of all children--including children with disabilities or
developmental delays, at-risk children, children from various minority groups and
cultures, and children with limited English skills. In their Guidelines for
Appropriate Curriculum Content and Assessment in Programs Serving Children Ages 3 Through
8, the National Association for the Education of Young Children and the National
Association of Early Childhood Specialists in State Departments of Education (1990)
describe the following characteristics of an appropriate early childhood curriculum:
- Is based on sound theoretical principles of how children learn and develop.
- Is designed to achieve long-range social, emotional, cognitive, and physical goals.
- Includes realistic and achievable expectations that allow children of varying abilities
to work at different levels on different activities.
- Reflects the needs and interests of individual children and incorporates a wide variety
of learning experiences.
- Builds upon what children already know.
- Engages children actively.
- Supports individual, cultural, and linguistic diversity, providing a balance between the
dominant culture and the minority culture.
- Emphasizes the value of social interaction.
- Is flexible and can be adapted to individual children or groups.
A diverse early education classroom also requires other curricular considerations. The
curriculum must balance learning the common core of knowledge from the dominant culture
(the English language, for example, or democratic values) with knowledge of minority
cultures (Derman-Sparks, 1992). To do so, the teacher must plan to connect
cultural activities to concrete, daily life through hands-on experiences, rather than
"visiting" other cultures on special occasions.
Teaching with a multicultural perspective encourages children to understand and appreciate
other cultures. Curricular units on families (perhaps using photos or making class books),
the local community, cooking, music, and work can all be helpful in accomplishing this
goal (Derman-Sparks & Anti-Bias Curriculum Task Force, 1989).
|